Great Nicobar Island Project: Balancing Development, Ecology, and Tribal Rights

The government has proposed a ₹91,000 crore mega infrastructure project in Great Nicobar Island, the southernmost part of the Andaman and Nicobar Islands. The project aims to transform the island into a strategic and economic hub.

Ecological Significance of Great Nicobar Island

• Tropical Rainforests: Great Nicobar contains pristine tropical rainforests that have remained largely undisturbed in their natural form, making them important for biodiversity conservation.
• Rare Coral Reefs: The island has unique and rare coral reef ecosystems that support diverse marine life and maintain ecological balance.
• Unique Biodiversity: Great Nicobar is home to rich biodiversity, including several rare species of flora and fauna found only in this region.
• Endemic Species: The island supports endemic species, meaning species that are found only in a specific geographical region and nowhere else in the world.
  • Nicobar Megapode: A rare endemic bird species found only in the Nicobar region. Destruction of its habitat could lead to its permanent extinction.
  • Leatherback Turtle: The Galathea Bay in Great Nicobar serves as an important nesting ground for the Leatherback Turtle, where it lays eggs and breeds.

UPSC Online Courses

Four Major Components of the Great Nicobar Project

• International Transshipment Port: The project includes the development of an International Transshipment Port at Galathea Bay.
  • A transshipment port is a facility where large ships unload cargo, which is then transferred to smaller ships for further transportation.
  • Importance:
    • It will reduce India’s dependence on foreign transshipment ports.
    • It will enhance India’s role in global maritime trade.
    • Its location near the Malacca Strait provides a major strategic and economic advantage.
• International Airport
  • The project includes the construction of an international airport with dual-use capacity.
  • It will serve both:
    • Civilian purposes such as passenger and commercial connectivity.
    • Military purposes to strengthen defence capabilities.
  • The airport has importance from a strategic security and defence perspective due to the island’s location.
• Power Infrastructure: The project proposes gas-based and solar-based power generation facilities.
  • These power facilities will provide energy support for:
    • New infrastructure development.
    • The proposed township.
    • Long-term economic activities on the island.
• New Township Development
  • A planned new township will be developed to support the project.
  • It will provide accommodation and facilities for:
    • Workers involved in construction and operations.
    • Government officials and administrators.
    • Supporting population associated with new infrastructure development.

Concerns Regarding the Great Nicobar Project

Environmental Impact

• The project requires the diversion and clearing of primary forests.
• Primary Forests: Forests that have remained largely untouched by human activities for centuries and maintain their natural ecological processes.

Major Concerns

• Loss of Biodiversity: Large-scale forest clearance may threaten the rich biodiversity of the island.
• Destruction of Endemic Species: Species found only in the Great Nicobar region may face the risk of extinction due to habitat loss.
• Irreversible Ecological Damage: The destruction of natural ecosystems, especially tropical rainforests, may not be restored once lost.

Issue with Compensatory Afforestation

• The government argues that trees removed for the project will be replaced through compensatory afforestation.
• However, planting trees in another region cannot replace the ecological value of a tropical rainforest ecosystem.
• Habitats of species like Nicobar Megapode and Leatherback Turtle cannot be recreated easily because they depend on specific geographical conditions.

Strategic Tag Controversy

• The project has been classified as “strategic” due to its importance for national security.

Concerns

• Environmental and project-related information has been restricted by citing national security reasons.
• Critics argue that using the strategic tag may reduce transparency and public accountability.
• The Public Investment Board (PIB) reportedly questioned whether the port had a genuine strategic purpose and considered it more of a commercial project.

Key Issue

The debate is about balancing:

• National security interests
• Environmental transparency
• Public accountability

Viability Gap Funding (VGF)

• Viability Gap Funding (VGF): A financial support mechanism provided by the government to make socially important but financially challenging projects economically viable.

Concern

• The project received approval, but government financial support under VGF was reportedly not approved.

UPSC Online Coaching

Key Questions

• If the project is important for national security, why is government funding support being denied?
• If it is only a commercial project, why is it being presented as a strategic national security initiative?

Core Conflict

The issue highlights the tension between:

• Economic objectives
• Strategic objectives

Tribal Rights

• Great Nicobar is home to two major indigenous communities:
  • Shompen people
  • Great Nicobarese people
• The Shompen community is recognised as a Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Group (PVTG).

Major Concerns

• Lack of complete information sharing regarding project impacts.
• Fear of displacement and loss of traditional habitats.
• Threat to traditional lifestyle and cultural identity.
• Loss of ancestral land due to large-scale development.

Main Issues Raised by Tribes

• Scale of the project: The island may not be able to absorb such large development.
• Lack of transparency: Concerns regarding environmental clearances and decision-making.
• Speed of implementation: The project is being pushed without adequate consultation.

Click to Know UPSC Coaching Centres in India

Way Forward

• Ensuring Transparency: The findings and recommendations of expert committees related to the project should be made publicly available to ensure accountability.
  • Complete information regarding the project should be shared with Parliament, citizens, and local communities to promote informed decision-making and public participation.
• Conducting a Comprehensive Cost-Benefit Analysis: A detailed cost-benefit analysis should be conducted to evaluate the overall impact of the project.
  • The assessment should consider:
    • Economic benefits generated by the project.
    • Environmental costs arising from ecological damage.
    • Hidden subsidies and financial implications borne by the government.
    • Land acquisition costs and associated social impacts.
    • Long-term ecological consequences of the project.
• Promoting Sustainable Development
  • The project should follow the principle of sustainable development by balancing multiple objectives.
  • Development planning should ensure harmony between:
    • Strategic security requirements
    • Economic growth and infrastructure development
    • Environmental protection and biodiversity conservation
    • Tribal rights and social justice.

Check Out UPSC CSE Books

Visit PW Store