India Trade Policy: Alcohol & Tobacco Duties, Public Health & Article 47

As India steps up its global trade talks, there is a temptation to treat all commodities as equal bargaining tools. However, India must not allow foreign alcohol and tobacco products to enter the country at low customs duties. 

• This is not merely a question of economics or protectionism. It is a constitutional, moral, and public health imperative.

Constitutional and Moral Obligations

• Article 47 and Directive Principles: Article 47 of the Constitution directs the State to endeavour to prohibit intoxicating drinks and drugs injurious to health.
• Spirit of the Constitution: Trade or economic policies must align with constitutional morality. 
  • The national interest cannot be separated from the protection of citizens’ health and social welfare.

Public Health Concerns

• Addiction and Mortality: WHO estimates indicate that around 40 million Indians suffer from alcohol addiction, while tobacco use causes over 10 lakh deaths annually in India, reflecting a major public health burden.
• No Safe Level of Consumption: Studies cited by WHO and The Lancet indicate that there is no safe level of alcohol consumption, as even small quantities can cause health harm.
• Disease Burden: Alcohol consumption is associated with several cancers, cardiovascular disease, liver disorders, and the broader rise of non-communicable diseases in India.
• Health Warning Proposals: International public health bodies have proposed mandatory warning labels on alcohol bottles that highlight links to cancer and other diseases.
• State-Level Prohibition: States such as Gujarat, Bihar, Nagaland, and Mizoram have imposed prohibition to protect public health.

Enroll now for UPSC Online Course

Global and Principled Position

• WTO Negotiation Strategy: India can adopt a principled stance in WTO negotiations on alcohol and tobacco, similar to its strong defence of affordable generic medicines in global trade discussions.
• Non-Negotiable Public Health Red Line: Tariffs and regulatory controls on health-hazardous products such as alcohol and tobacco may be treated as non-negotiable safeguards for public health.

Check Out UPSC CSE Books

Visit PW Store

Conclusion

India should adopt a firm, health-first stance in trade negotiations, ensuring that economic growth aligns with the constitutional vision of a healthier, socially responsible society.