IRDAI Insurance Distribution Reforms: Commissions, EoM Limits and Consumer Protection

Subject: GS Paper 3: Indian Economy

Context: The Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI) has proposed reforms to insurance distribution, commissions, expenses, and consumer protection. 

• The proposals have triggered a sharp fall in insurance-related stocks.

UPSC Online Preparation

About Insurance

• Insurance is a financial safeguard that protects individuals and organisations against unforeseen losses and risks.
  • It is a contract between the insurer and policyholder, under which the insurer provides financial compensation for specified losses in exchange for a premium.
  • It helps manage risks arising from events such as accidents, theft, fire, property damage, illness, or other uncertainties.
• Insurance Penetration: It is measured as the total insurance premium collected from life and non-life insurance as a percentage of Gross Domestic Product (GDP).

Status of Insurance Sector In India

• Large Market, Low Penetration: 
  • India is the world’s 10th-largest insurance market, but insurance penetration was only 3.7% in 2024-25.
  • The Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) limit in the insurance sector was raised to 100% with the objective of increasing insurance penetration.
• Persistence Challenge: The sector faces the problem of low persistence, as distributors earn significantly more from selling new policies than from retaining existing policyholders.
  • Persistency refers to the continued payment of premiums and retention of an insurance policy. 
• Distribution Imbalance: Insurance distribution is heavily influenced by commissions, with commission growth significantly exceeding premium growth in some channels.
• Low-Ticket Insurance: There are concerns that lower-margin, low-ticket policies, which help expand insurance coverage in non-Tier-1 cities and among lower-income groups, may receive less distribution incentive.
• Distribution Channels: Banks and online aggregators are important insurance-distribution channels, with online policies showing higher five-year persistency than policies sold through corporate agents.

Key Proposals

• Commission Caps: Limit first-year commissions on life insurance to 20% of the premium for distributors and 25% for agents, reducing the amount paid to sellers.
• Lower Distribution Expenses: Reduce the Expense of Management (EoM) to 12.5% for life insurers and 20% for general insurers over five years. EoM includes administrative and distribution costs, including commissions.
• Consumer Protection: Curb mis-selling, excessive commission-driven sales, and dark patterns to better protect insurance buyers.
• Better Market Competition: Encourage customers to choose insurance based on price, suitability,and product quality, rather than sales being driven mainly by commissions.

Why did insurance stocks fall?

• Lower Commission Income: The proposed commission caps could reduce insurance distributors’ income, putting pressure on their profitability.
• Greater Impact on Online Aggregators: Platforms such as Policybazaar and TurtleMint have high customer acquisition costs and depend heavily on upfront commissions. Lower commissions could therefore affect their earnings more significantly.
• Impact on Banks: Insurance distribution is a high-margin, capital-light source of income for banks. Lower commissions could reduce the income banks earn from selling insurance products.
• Pressure from EoM Limits: The proposed Expense of Management (EoM) limits are lower than the current EoM levels of most insurers. 20 of 22 life insurers and 28 of 31 general insurers currently exceed the proposed 2028-29 limits, creating pressure to reduce expenses.

Click to Know UPSC OnlyIAS Coaching Centres

Impact of The Proposed Reforms

• Consumer Protection: Reduce mis-selling and dark patterns, thereby strengthening protection for insurance buyers.
• Market Competition: Encourage competition based on pricing, product suitability and quality rather than commission-led sales.
• Distributor Profitability: Lower commission caps could reduce the profit margins of insurance distributors.
• Banking Sector: Lower commissions could affect banks’ insurance-distribution income, an important high-margin and capital-light revenue stream.
• Low-Ticket Policies: Reduced payouts may disincentivise the sale of lower-ticket, lower-margin policies, which are important for expanding insurance coverage in non-Tier-1 cities and among lower-income groups.

News Source: IE

Check Out UPSC CSE Books

Visit PW Store