Answer:

Introduction:

The Aadhaar Payment Bridge System (APBS), a digital initiative by the National Payments Corporation of India (NPCI), integrates Aadhaar numbers as a central component in the disbursement of government benefits and subsidies. Conceptualized to enhance the efficiency and transparency of direct benefit transfers, APBS represents a significant step towards financial inclusion. However, its implementation has raised concerns about its impact on marginalized and vulnerable groups in society.

Body:

Concept and Implementation Challenges:

• APBS was designed to simplify the process of receiving government subsidies by linking them directly to Aadhaar numbers. The system aimed to reduce the need for multiple account details, making transfers more straightforward and secure​​.
• However, the rapid rollout of the system, particularly during the Jan Dhan Yojana, led to haphazard account openings and Aadhaar seeding, creating confusion with multiple accounts per individual and inadequate consent procedures​​.

Impact on Marginalized Groups:

• The necessity for eKYC (electronic Know Your Customer) posed significant challenges, especially for the poor and elderly who were unfamiliar with these processes or faced difficulties with biometric authentication, leading to account blockages and benefit disruptions​​​​.
• Diverted payments due to the APBS’s automatic transfer to the latest mapped account affected many, particularly in rural areas like Jharkhand, where a significant percentage of MGNREGA wages were redirected to unrelated accounts, causing financial distress​​.

Issues of Exclusion and Human Rights:

• The emphasis on biometric authentication led to failures in recognizing individuals whose biometric data changed over time, such as manual laborers and the elderly, thus excluding them from receiving benefits​​.
• Marginalized communities often faced barriers due to a lack of access to necessary information and assistance, further hindering their ability to benefit from the system​​.

Lack of Accountability and Transparency:

• The complex and opaque nature of APBS created difficulties in addressing issues of diverted or rejected payments, with little recourse for beneficiaries facing such problems​​.
• Concerns about privacy and data security arose due to the centralization of personal data and the potential for misuse.

Conclusion:

While the Aadhaar Payment Bridge System was introduced with the objective of streamlining the distribution of benefits and promoting financial inclusion, its implementation has revealed critical gaps that disproportionately impact marginalized and vulnerable groups. The challenges of haphazard account seeding, eKYC compliance, and diverted payments highlight the need for a more inclusive and sensitive approach. Addressing these issues requires not only technological improvements but also a comprehensive understanding of the diverse needs and limitations of the affected populations. It is imperative to ensure that initiatives like APBS are not just technologically sound but also empathetic and responsive to the realities of those they are meant to serve.

DOWNLOAD PDF