Answer:

Introduction:

Fiscal federalism in India entails the division of responsibilities and resources between the central and state governments, with the Finance Commission playing a key role in recommending tax proceeds distribution. Equitable intergovernmental transfers, involving fund transfers from the central to state governments, are vital for balanced regional development, reducing fiscal imbalances, and promoting cooperative federalism.

Body:

Challenges:

• Horizontal Imbalances:
  • Unequal economic development: States like Maharashtra and Tamil Nadu are economically more developed than states like Bihar and Uttar Pradesh. 
  • This leads to varying fiscal capacities among the states.
  • Regional disparities: There are significant disparities in the socio-economic indicators of different states, which makes it challenging to ensure equitable intergovernmental transfers.

• Vertical Imbalances:
  • Disparities in revenue and expenditure: The central government has a higher revenue-raising capacity while the states have more expenditure responsibilities. 
  • This leads to a mismatch between the revenue and expenditure of the states.

• Political Considerations:
  • Allegations of bias: There have been allegations of political bias in the allocation of funds to the states, which undermines the principles of equitable distribution.
• Inadequate assessment of needs:
  • Inadequate data and assessment: The assessment of the needs of the states may not always be accurate due to inadequate data and varying criteria for allocation.

Potential Solutions:

• Strengthening the Role of Finance Commission:
  • The Finance Commission should be strengthened to ensure that its recommendations are implemented in letter and spirit. 
  • This will help in ensuring equitable distribution of resources based on objective criteria.
• Transparent and Objective Criteria:
  • The criteria for allocation of funds should be transparent, objective, and based on the latest available data.
  • This will help in reducing allegations of bias and ensuring equitable distribution.
• Addressing Regional Disparities:
  • Special attention should be given to the states that are lagging behind in terms of socio-economic indicators. 
  • This will help in reducing regional disparities and promoting balanced development.
• Strengthening Local Governments:
  • Local governments should be strengthened by providing them with adequate resources and powers. 
  • This will help in ensuring that the funds are utilized effectively at the grassroots level.

Conclusion: 

Equitable intergovernmental transfers are essential for promoting balanced regional development, reducing fiscal imbalances, and strengthening cooperative federalism in India. It is important to address the challenges associated with intergovernmental transfers by strengthening the role of the Finance Commission, ensuring transparent and objective criteria for allocation, addressing regional disparities, and strengthening local governments. This will help in ensuring that the resources are distributed equitably among the states and utilized effectively for the welfare of the people.

DOWNLOAD PDF