Brain Death Certification in India: Supreme Court Review, EEG & Angiogram Debate

30 Apr 2026

The Supreme Court of India is reviewing brain death certification amid allegations of misuse to facilitate organ harvesting and lack of standardised medical testing.

The Supreme Court is seeking expert opinion from All India Institute of Medical Sciences on adding confirmatory tests such as electroencephalogram (EEG) and angiogram.

UPSC Online Coaching

What is Brain Death?

Brain death OR brain stem death is the irreversible cessation of all brain activity, including vital functions like breathing.
Condition:
- No brainstem reflexes (pupil, gag, pain response)
- No spontaneous breathing (apnea)
- Patient survives only on ventilator support
Need for Declaration:
- Essential for deceased organ donation (heart, lungs, liver, kidneys)
- Avoids risk to living donors
- Provides legal clarity for withdrawal of life support

About Electroencephalogram (EEG)

An EEG is a non-invasive diagnostic test that records the brain’s electrical activity to assess functional status and detect abnormalities.
Instruments Used:
- Surface electrodes placed on the scalp
- Amplifier to enhance electrical signals
- Computer system for recording and interpretation
Procedure : Electrodes capture neuronal electrical impulses, producing wave patterns (alpha, beta, delta) for clinical analysis.
Key Indications:
- Confirmation of brain death in absence of electrical activity
- Diagnosis of epilepsy and seizure disorders
- Assessment of coma, encephalopathy, and brain injuries
Limitations:
- Can be affected by external interference
- May not conclusively establish brain death without clinical correlation

About Angiogram

An angiogram is an imaging technique used to visualise blood vessels and assess blood flow, especially in the brain.
Instruments Used:
- Contrast dye (radiopaque substance)
- Catheter inserted into blood vessels
- X-ray or fluoroscopy imaging system
Procedure: Contrast dye is injected into arteries, and real-time imaging tracks blood flow to detect blockages or absence of circulation.
Key Indications:
- Confirmation of brain death in absence of cerebral blood flow.
- Detection of vascular abnormalities (aneurysm, stroke, blockage)
- Evaluation before neurosurgical procedures
Limitations:
- Invasive procedure with risk of complications
- Requires specialised infrastructure and expertise

Current Protocol in India for Brain Death Declaration

Legal Basis: Governed under the Transplantation of Human Organs and Tissues Act (THOTA), 1994, recognizes brain stem death as legal death.
Medical Board: It can only be declared by a 4-member panel including a doctor-in-charge, neurologist/neurosurgeon, treating physician and an independent doctor.
Repeated Certification: Brain death must be confirmed twice (6–12 hours apart)
Clinical Tests: Bedside tests (apnea test, brainstem reflexes) there is no mandatory requirement for EEG and angiogram.

Challenges in Brain Death Declaration

Lack of Training & Awareness: Many doctors lack formal training in certification and there is no uniform curriculum in teaching hospitals
Subjectivity in Testing: Apnea test may be inconsistently applied as videography mandate is often not followed
Infrastructure Constraints: Advanced tests (EEG, angiogram) are unavailable in smaller hospitals
- This could reduce already low organ donation rates
Ethical & Trust Deficit: Allegations of premature declaration for organ harvesting.
- Public mistrust affects consent for donation

Click to Know UPSC OnlyIAS Coaching Centres

Conclusion

Strengthening transparency, training, and standardised protocols is essential to ensure ethical brain death certification while boosting India’s organ donation ecosystem.

Check Out UPSC CSE Books

Visit PW Store