Answer

Introduction

The recent airstrikes by Pakistan on Kabul and Kandahar and the declaration of “open war” mark a serious escalation in Afghanistan–Pakistan relations. Recurrent border clashes, militant safe-haven allegations, and failed ceasefires underline deep-rooted structural tensions, posing grave risks to South Asian regional stability and India’s strategic interests.

Causes of Recurring Tensions between Pakistan and Afghanistan

• Cross-Border Militancy Allegations: Pakistan accuses the Taliban regime of allowing anti-Pakistan militant groups to operate from Afghan soil.
• Border Disputes and the Durand Line Issue: The Durand Line remains historically contested, fuelling frequent skirmishes.
• Tit-for-Tat Military Escalation: Retaliatory airstrikes and land offensives are cyclical.
  Eg: Pakistan’s strikes on Kabul, Paktia, and Kandahar followed Afghan attacks on Pakistani border troops (February 2026).
• Failure of Ceasefire Mechanisms: Qatar- and Turkey-brokered ceasefire efforts failed; Saudi Arabia recently mediated prisoner release.
• Rise of Transnational Terror Groups: The presence of groups like ISIS-K exacerbates instability.
  Eg: Islamic State–Khorasan claimed attacks in Islamabad and Kabul.

Implications for Regional Stability

• Escalation into Open Conflict: Formal declaration of “open war” risks prolonged military confrontation.
• Civilian Casualties and Humanitarian Crisis: Airstrikes and shelling affect refugees and border populations.
  Eg: UN mission reported 13 civilians killed in Nangarhar and Paktika; refugees injured near Torkham.
• Border Closures Disrupt Trade: Land crossings have largely remained shut since October 2025.
  Eg: Closure of Torkham crossing affects regional transit trade.
• Terror Vacuum Expansion: Instability may strengthen extremist outfits exploiting chaos.
• External Power Involvement: International actors may intervene diplomatically or strategically.
  Eg: U.S. statement supporting Pakistan’s “right to defend itself”; Qatar, Turkey, Saudi mediation efforts.

Implications for India’s Strategic Interests

• Security Concerns in the Region: Instability can embolden anti-India terror networks.
• Connectivity and Trade Disruptions: India’s Central Asia outreach via Afghanistan faces setbacks.
  Eg: India’s investment in Chabahar Port aimed to bypass Pakistan depends on Afghan stability.
• Diplomatic Balancing Challenge: India must cautiously engage both Kabul and Islamabad.
  Eg: India has maintained limited diplomatic presence in Kabul since 2022.
• Risk of Radicalisation Spillover: Escalation may strengthen extremist narratives in the region.
• Geopolitical Realignment Pressures: Heightened conflict may invite greater Chinese or U.S. involvement, affecting India’s strategic calculus.

Conclusion

Sustainable peace demands structured border management, credible counter-terror commitments, and revival of regional dialogue under multilateral platforms like SAARC or SCO. India must pursue calibrated diplomacy, strengthen counter-terror cooperation, and promote economic connectivity initiatives that anchor Afghanistan within a stable and cooperative South Asian framework.

DOWNLOAD PDF