Rajya Sabha Nomination: Eligibility, Rejection Grounds & Disqualification Rules

Recently, the Returning Officer (RO)—the official in charge of running the election—rejected the Rajya Sabha nomination of senior Congress leader Meenakshi Natarajan from Madhya Pradesh.

• The RO ruled that Natarajan submitted an incomplete background affidavit (Form 26) by hiding a pending court case (a private complaint) against her in Telangana.

UPSC Online Preparation

Understanding Rajya Sabha Nominations: (UPSC CSE Prelims 2001, 2004, & 2012)

• The Constitutional Composition (Article 80): The Rajya Sabha can have a maximum of 250 members. 
  • Out of these, 12 members are directly chosen by the President in fields like literature, science, art, and social service. 
  • The remaining 238 members represent the States and Union Territories.
• The Electoral College: Elected members of the State Legislative Assemblies (MLAs) vote to choose the Rajya Sabha members for their specific state.
• The System of Voting: The election uses a system called Proportional Representation by means of the Single Transferable Vote. 
• The Open Ballot System: To stop political corruption, bribery, and lawmakers secretly voting against their own party, Rajya Sabha elections use an Open Ballot System. 
• The Need for Backers (Section 34 of RPA, 1951): A person cannot just nominate themselves. 
  • To make sure only serious candidates apply, the application paper must be signed and supported by at least 10 MLAs of that state, or by 10% of the total MLAs in that state’s assembly, whichever number is smaller.

Explore UPSC Foundation Courses

Explore UPSC Foundation Courses

Grounds for Disqualification (Legally Unfit to Hold Office)

These are the strict, long-term legal bars set by the Constitution (Article 102) and the Representation of the People Act, 1951. A person is completely banned from being a Member of Parliament if they meet any of the following:

• Holding an Office of Profit: If they hold a paid job under the central or state governments that could make them biased or dependent on government favors (unless that specific job is exempted by a law made by Parliament).
• Mental State and Financial Standing: If a competent court officially declares them to be of unsound mind, or if they are an undischarged insolvent (meaning they are bankrupt and have unpaid debts they are legally unable to clear).
• Citizenship Issues: If they lose their Indian citizenship, give it up, or voluntarily pledge loyalty to a foreign country.
• Serious Criminal Convictions (Section 8 of RPA): If a court finds them guilty of a crime and sentences them to two or more years in prison. 
  • The Supreme Court has ruled that this disqualification hits instantly the moment the judge announces the sentence, removing them from office immediately.
• Corrupt Practices (Section 8A): If they are found guilty of election fraud, bribery, or treating voters unfairly during a previous election.
• Failing to Show Election Costs (Section 10A): If they fail to hand in a correct and timely account of all the money they spent during an election campaign.
• The Anti-Defection Law (10th Schedule): If they voluntarily leave the political party that got them elected, or if they vote against their party’s strict orders inside the Parliament house.

Grounds for Rejection of Nomination Papers (Procedural Invalidation)

• Hiding Material Facts (The Blank Column Rule): Every candidate must fill out a background declaration sheet known as Form 26. 
  • On this form, they must honestly list their personal wealth, family assets, loans, school qualifications, and any pending police or court cases. 
  • If a candidate leaves spaces completely blank, or intentionally hides a court case, it is legally treated as a major defect, and the RO is forced to throw out the application.
• Lack of Valid Backers: If the application form does not have the genuine signatures of the required number of MLAs (the 10 MLAs or 10% rule mentioned earlier).
• Failing to Pay the Deposit: If the candidate forgets to pay the mandatory security deposit fee. Currently, this fee is ₹10,000 for general candidates and ₹5,000 for candidates belonging to Scheduled Castes (SC) or Scheduled Tribes (ST).
• Missing the Official Oath: If the candidate fails to take the official loyalty oath to the Constitution before the authorized election official within the strict timeline allowed for filing applications.

Click to Explore UPSC Offline Coaching

Important Supreme Court Rulings on the Voter’s “Right to Know”

• Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR) Case (2002): The Supreme Court ruled that regular citizens have a fundamental right to know about the background of the people trying to lead them. 
  • This right is protected under Article 19(1)(a) (Freedom of Speech and Expression). The court made it mandatory for candidates to put their wealth, education, and criminal history out in the open.
• Resurgence India vs. Election Commission (2013): The Court stated that candidates cannot leave blank boxes on their Form 26 background sheets. 
  • Leaving boxes blank makes the entire form illegal. If a section does not apply to a candidate, they must explicitly write “Nil” or “Not Applicable” so voters know the information was not simply hidden.
• Satish Ukey Case (2019): The Supreme Court clearly stated that intentionally hiding any pending criminal case in an election form is an illegal and “corrupt practice.”
  • If a candidate wins an election but is later found to have hidden a court case, their entire election victory can be canceled and declared empty by a court.

Check Out UPSC CSE Books

Visit PW Store

DOWNLOAD PDF