Subject: GS 2: Polity & Governance
Context: Allegations of donation theft at the Shri Ram Janmabhoomi Temple, Ayodhya, have brought attention to the governance, security and audit of temple donations.
UPSC Course Fees Online
Governance Models Across Major Temples
- Shri Ram Janmabhoomi Temple (Ayodhya): Trust-Based Administration
- Trust-Led Governance: The Shri Ram Janmabhoomi Teerth Kshetra Trust manages donations through its internal administrative structure rather than under a dedicated statutory framework.
- Donation Process: Donations from hundis are counted jointly by trust officials, State Bank of India (SBI) representatives and outsourced counting personnel under CCTV surveillance before being deposited into the Trust’s bank account.
- Administrative Concentration: Decision-making regarding financial administration, appointments and oversight remains largely within the Trust rather than involving independent statutory authorities.
- Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams (TTD): Institutionalised Oversight
- Multi-Agency Supervision: Permanent finance officials, nationalised bank representatives, vetted volunteers and the temple vigilance wing jointly supervise the Parakamani (donation counting) process.
- Strict Security Protocols: Personnel wear pocketless uniforms, undergo frisking, and cash movement is protected through armoured transport and continuous surveillance.
- Shri Jagannath Temple (Puri): Statutory Procedure
- Codified Legal Framework: Donation management follows procedures prescribed under the Shri Jagannath Temple Act, ensuring standardised financial administration.
- Independent Oversight: Hundis are opened in the presence of the Temple Administrator, authorised gazetted officers and Managing Committee members, with mandatory record-keeping and statutory registers.
- Shri Mata Vaishno Devi Shrine: Corporate-Style Management
- Professional Administration: Dedicated committees comprising accounts officers, security officials and administrative managers supervise donation handling rather than individual trustees.
- Integrated Logistics: Secure transport systems, including specialised vehicles and helicopter services where necessary, facilitate movement of valuables.
- Shri Siddhivinayak Temple (Mumbai): Independent Verification
- Multi-Stakeholder Oversight: Donation counting takes place in the presence of trustees, executive officers, bank representatives and independent auditors, ensuring checks at every stage.
- Shri Kashi Vishwanath Temple (Varanasi): Government Participation
- Administrative Oversight: The district administration, including a Sub-Divisional Magistrate (SDM), supervises opening of donation boxes alongside bank officials and retired government officers.
- Audit Trail: Every transaction generates deposit receipts, while jewellery is valued by government-approved appraisers before secure custody.
How the Ram Temple Differs
- Trust Deed Instead of Statute: Unlike many major temples governed through dedicated State legislation, the Ram Temple functions through a trust deed, with no exclusive statutory framework prescribing financial administration.
- Limited Statutory Oversight: Older temple boards operate under laws that mandate government oversight, statutory audits, defined administrative hierarchies and financial accountability, whereas the Ram Temple relies primarily on internal trust governance.
- Concentrated Administrative Responsibility: Financial administration is largely vested in Trust office-bearers rather than being distributed among statutory administrators, government nominees or magistrates.
- Absence of Mandatory Government Audit: The Trust is not subject to compulsory financial audits by the Union or State Governments, unlike several statutory temple boards.
Click to Know UPSC Coaching Centres in India
Constitutional and Governance Perspective:
- Article 25 & Article 26: Guarantee the freedom of religion and permit religious denominations to manage their own affairs, subject to public order, morality, health and other constitutional provisions.
- Article 14: Public institutions handling large public contributions should function with fairness, transparency and accountability.
- Directive Principles (Article 38): The State should promote institutions that advance social justice, good governance and public confidence.
- Public Trust Doctrine: Institutions managing resources voluntarily contributed by the public are expected to uphold the highest standards of fiduciary responsibility and financial integrity.
|
4 Jul 2026
