The Emergence and Impact of Left Movements in India: Marxism, Socialism, and Nationalism

As the third decade of the twentieth century unfolded in India, the political landscape was already undergoing profound changes. It was a time when the traditional struggle for freedom intersected with a broader spectrum of political ideologies, leading to the emergence of the Left movements. This period witnessed the burgeoning of socialist ideas, which intertwined with the national movement, shaping the aspirations of independence with a vision of socioeconomic equality.

The Gandhian era, characterized by non-violent resistance and civil disobedience, continued to hold sway over the masses. However, it simultaneously gave rise to critical voices that sought a more radical approach to India’s liberation. The appeal of Marxism and socialist philosophies, gaining momentum worldwide, inspired a generation of Indian leaders and intellectuals who were grappling with the challenges of colonial subjugation and internal social inequalities.

Spread of Marxist and Socialist Ideas

Origins in India

The emergence and growth of the left movement in India was the result of a combination of factors such as the development of Indian Industries, economic stress caused by the world war and the success of the Bolshevik Revolution in Russia. Ideas from Marx and other socialist thinkers began to resonate in India. Inspired by the Soviet Revolution, young nationalists grew dissatisfied with Gandhian philosophies and advocated radical solutions for India’s socio-political challenges.

Key Figures and Contributions

• M.N. Roy: A central figure in introducing communist ideas to India. He founded the Communist Party of India (CPI) in Tashkent in 1920 and was elected to the leadership of Comintern.
• Jawaharlal Nehru and Subhash Chandra Bose: These leaders, part of the Congress’s left wing, were heavily influenced by socialist ideologies.
• S.A. Dange and Others: Dange, along with Muzaffar Ahmed, Shaukat Usmani, and Nalini Gupta, were arrested in the Kanpur Bolshevik Conspiracy Case of 1924. These figures, among others, played a crucial role in spreading communist ideas.

Emergence and Growth of the Communist Party of India (CPI)

The CPI’s foundation was formalized at the Indian Communist Conference in Kanpur in 1925 which was organised by Satyabhakt and presided over by Singarvelu Chettiar of Madras. The subsequent years saw the government cracking down on communists, notably in the Meerut conspiracy case of 1929. Despite the challenges, workers’ and peasants’ parties across India continued to propagate Marxist and communist ideas, aligning closely with the Congress. Following the endorsement of supporting the national movement, as encouraged by Lenin, the Communist Party of India (CPI) instructed its members to align with the Congress and establish a robust left-wing presence within it.

Definition of the Left

The “Left” in the political context refers to a spectrum of political ideologies that traditionally advocate for social equality, economic equity, and the well-being of the common people. 

• Leftist ideologies emphasize the need for government intervention to achieve these goals, which can include social ownership, the redistribution of wealth, and the establishment of a welfare state to protect the rights of workers, minorities, and the underprivileged.
• In the Indian context, the Left movement has been synonymous with a range of political parties and organizations that advocate for similar principles, adapted to the unique socio-political landscape of the country. 
• • These include various shades of socialism, communism, and Marxism. 
  • They prioritize the agrarian sector, labour rights, social justice, and secularism, aiming to fight against feudalism, imperialism, and later, neoliberal policies.

Circumstances Favouring Growth of Left Ideologies in India

• Colonial Exploitation and the Quest for Independence:
  • Catalyst for Leftist Ideologies: The initial impetus for the rise of leftist ideologies in India was provided by the struggle against British colonialism. 
  • Economic Exploitation and Social Reform: The exploitation of the country’s resources and the severe economic distress faced by farmers and workers under the British Raj created a fertile ground for ideologies that called for social and economic reforms.
• Economic Disparities and Feudalism: 
  • Enduring Feudal Structures: Post-independence, the persistence of feudal structures and vast economic disparities, with wealth concentrated in the hands of a few, made leftist ideologies appealing to those at the lower end of the socio-economic spectrum. 
  • Leftist Ideologies in Rural Areas: This was especially potent in rural areas where land reforms were seen as a necessity for breaking the hold of landlords and redistributing land to the tillers.
• Global Influence and the Cold War Era: 
  • The global influence of the Soviet Union and the spread of Marxist-Leninist thought played a significant role in shaping Indian Left movements. 
  • The success of the Russian Revolution and later, the Chinese Revolution, inspired many Indian intellectuals and political leaders, who saw in communism a path to modernization and economic development that could be an alternative to Western capitalism.
• Education and Intellectual Milieu: 
  • The expansion of education and the increased accessibility of leftist literature also contributed to the growth of socialist and communist ideologies. 
  • Universities and colleges became hotbeds of leftist thought, with student movements playing a pivotal role in the spread of these ideologies.
• Socio-Political Movements: 
  • Various socio-political movements in India, such as the anti-caste movements, which emphasized equality and social justice, found common cause with the Left’s ideology.
  • The Left provided a platform for marginalized communities to fight for their rights, thereby integrating social reform with economic justice.
• Labour Movements and Trade Unionism: 
  • The organization of workers in industries and plantations into unions was a direct catalyst for the growth of leftist thought. 
  • Labour movements fought against exploitation and for the rights of workers, drawing heavily from socialist principles.

Nehru’s Contribution

Jawaharlal Nehru played a pivotal role in shaping the socialist vision within the Indian national movement, particularly from 1929 onwards. At the Lahore Congress of 1929, he became the president and advocated for the integration of socio-economic content into the concept of freedom. Nehru emphasized that political freedom must lead to economic emancipation for the masses, laying the foundation for a socialist society.

• Early Influences on Nehru’s Socialist Ideals: Nehru’s interest in economic matters grew during his involvement with the peasant movement in eastern U.P. in 1920-21. 
  • His exposure to international perspectives at the 1927 International Congress against Colonial Oppression in Brussels, and collaboration with Subhas in forming the Independence for India League in 1928, further solidified his commitment to a socialist revision of India’s economic structure.
• Nehru’s Articulation of Socialist Commitment (1933-36): Between 1933 and 1936, Nehru expressed his commitment to socialism passionately, stating that the key to solving global and Indian problems lies in socialism. He stressed the scientific and economic sense of the term and incorporated class analysis and class struggle into his ideological framework.
  • Nehru’s relationship with Mahatma Gandhi during this period was complex. While critical of Gandhi’s approach, which neglected class conflicts and promoted harmony between exploiters and the exploited, Nehru recognized Gandhi’s radical role in Indian society. 
    • Despite disagreements, Nehru aimed to influence and transform the Congress, avoiding a separate left-wing organization.

Conclusion

The rise of Leftist groups in India during the early 1900s greatly influenced the country’s social and political landscape. Driven by discontent with colonial rule and economic disparity, these movements introduced new ideas that both backed and challenged Gandhi’s approach to attaining independence. The Left, under the guidance of important leaders like M.N. Roy and Jawaharlal Nehru, took inspiration from socialist uprisings globally and were crucial in advocating for socio-economic changes to promote greater societal equality in India.

DOWNLOAD PDF