Ideological Differences Between Gandhi and Bose on Social Justice, Caste, and Women’s Rights

The contrasting visions of Mohandas K. Gandhi and Subhash Chandra Bose on India’s independence movement offer a profound exploration of the nation’s struggle. The debate over caste, untouchability, and women’s rights in India was profoundly shaped by the contrasting visions of Mahatma Gandhi and Subhash Chandra Bose. While Gandhi advocated for moral reform and the preservation of certain traditional values, Bose sought revolutionary change to dismantle societal hierarchies. Their differing approaches to social justice, caste equality, and women’s empowerment continue to resonate in contemporary discussions of India’s social transformation.

Caste and Untouchability

• Mohandas K. Gandhi
• Gandhi’s Opposition to Untouchability: Gandhi’s stance on caste and untouchability was multifaceted. He was unequivocally against untouchability, viewing it as a blight on Hindu society and a major impediment to India’s moral and social progress. 
• Untouchability and Swaraj: For Gandhi, the eradication of this practice was essential for the realization of Swaraj—self-rule—not just in the political sense but also in terms of individual and collective self-purification.
• The Controversy of Varna: While he fought against untouchability, Gandhi’s support for the varna system—a classification of society into four broad groups based on occupation and duty—was contentious. 
  • He believed that the varna system, if practiced in its purest form without the distortions that had crept in over the centuries, would lead to a harmonious and functional society where everyone performed their duties without a sense of hierarchy or discrimination. 
  • However, this view was not universally accepted, and many criticized Gandhi for apparently preserving the caste structure.

Enroll now for UPSC Online Course

Subhash Chandra Bose

• Bose’s Revolutionary Vision: Bose’s vision for India’s social structure was revolutionary and egalitarian. 
  • He envisaged a socialist revolution that would dismantle the existing caste hierarchies, creating a society where all individuals were equal regardless of their birth or occupation. 
• Advocacy for Social Reform: Bose was an advocate for inter-caste marriages and publicly condemned untouchability. 
  • He drew inspiration from Vivekananda, believing that India’s advancement depended on the upliftment of the oppressed and marginalized communities.
• Egalitarianism in Practice: Bose’s commitment to social equality was not only part of his rhetoric but also implemented in practice through the Indian National Army, which operated on egalitarian principles and actively worked to break down caste barriers and promote unity among its ranks.
• Gandhi’s Idealism vs. Bose’s Revolutionary Zeal
• Gandhi’s Idealistic Approach: Gandhi’s approach to caste was that of an idealistic reformer who sought to transform society through moral upliftment and ethical revival. 
• Bose’s Revolutionary Vision: He believed in changing hearts and minds to rid society of the scourge of untouchability. 
  • Bose, by contrast, was a revolutionary who sought structural change, aiming to replace the old order with a new one where caste was irrelevant.
• Continuing Challenges
• Both leaders left a lasting legacy in the fight against caste discrimination, though their approaches differed significantly. 
• Gandhi’s advocacy for a duty-based societal structure and Bose’s push for a casteless society reflect the ongoing debate in India about how best to address the deep-rooted issues of caste and untouchability. 
• Their efforts laid the groundwork for subsequent generations to continue striving for a society where every individual has the opportunity to realize their potential free from the constraints of birth-based hierarchies.

Women

• Mohandas K. Gandhi
• Advocacy for Women’s Empowerment: Gandhi was a pivotal figure in elevating the status of women in India. He regarded calling women the weaker sex as an injustice and sought to bring them out of the confines of their traditional roles. 
• Radical Involvement of Women in the Freedom Struggle: His efforts to involve women in the freedom struggle were indeed radical for the time, challenging social norms like purdah and the reluctance to involve women in political activism.
• Gandhi’s Social Reforms: His opposition to societal ills affecting women—such as child marriage, dowry, and the mistreatment of widows—was part of his broader agenda for social reform. 
  • While Gandhi envisioned equality between men and women, he did hold traditional views about their roles. 
• He saw women as inherently possessing the qualities required for nurturing the family and the home, which he valued as essential to society’s wellbeing. 
• However, his vision did not advocate for women to endure domestic oppression silently; he encouraged them to stand against ill-treatment and seek freedom from domestic slavery.
• Subhash Chandra Bose
• Bose’s vision for women was notably progressive and aligned with his revolutionary ideals. 
• He ardently believed in women’s equality and their right to participate fully in national life, including the fight for independence. 
  • He differed from totalitarian regimes of the time, asserting that women should stand shoulder to shoulder with men in the struggle for freedom.
• Commitment to Women’s Empowerment: As the leader of the Indian National Army, Bose created the Rani of Jhansi Regiment, an all-female combat unit, showcasing his commitment to women’s empowerment. 
• Advocacy for Women’s Emancipation: His belief in women’s emancipation went beyond their participation in the national struggle; he advocated for comprehensive education for women, abolishment of purdah, support for widow remarriage, and raising awareness about women’s social and legal rights.
• Gandhi’s Moral Reform vs. Bose’s Radical Equality
• Traditional Morality vs. Radical Equality: While Gandhi’s approach to uplifting women focused on their moral and ethical role within a traditional framework, Bose championed a more radical equality that sought to break down societal barriers and empower women in all spheres of life. 
• Gandhi’s Societal Duties vs. Bose’s Equality and Empowerment: Gandhi’s advocacy for women’s rights was constrained by his broader vision of societal duties, while Bose envisioned a society where women enjoyed the same freedoms and responsibilities as men, both in domestic life and in the public sphere.
• Impact on Women’s Liberation
• Both leaders significantly influenced the trajectory of women’s liberation in India. Gandhi’s mass movements brought women into the public sphere in an unprecedented way, and Bose’s practical initiatives provided models for women’s active participation in areas previously dominated by men.

Education

• Mohandas K. Gandhi
• Critique of Colonial Education: Gandhi’s views on education were inextricably linked to his critique of colonial rule, particularly the British system of education, which he believed disconnected Indians from their cultural roots. 
• Advocacy for Vernacular Education: He vehemently opposed the use of English as a medium of instruction and advocated for education in the vernacular to foster a closer connection between education and the local environment. 
•  Call for Free and Compulsory Education: His call for free and compulsory education for children between the ages of seven and fourteen was groundbreaking for the time and reflective of his commitment to universal access to education.
  • Gandhi’s concept of ‘Nai Talim’ or ‘New Education’ emphasized a holistic development approach, incorporating moral principles, physical training, and intellectual development. 
• Education as a Transformative Process: He saw education as a transformative process that cultivated wisdom and enlightenment, not merely literacy or vocational skills. 
  • Gandhi’s distinction between knowledge and wisdom highlighted his belief that education should lead to spiritual growth and a deep understanding of life’s greater truths.
• Integrating Hindu Scriptures and Manual Labour: In his vision, the incorporation of Hindu scriptures was not about religious indoctrination but about imparting values of discipline and self-restraint. 
  • Nai Talim proposed an education system where academic learning was integrated with purposeful manual labour, aligning with his vision of making villages self-sufficient economic units.
• Subhash Chandra Bose
• Pragmatic Education Strategy: Bose’s approach to education was pragmatic and future-oriented. He recognized the critical role of higher education, particularly in science and technology, for nation-building and industrial advancement. 
  • He sought to create an educational environment that would facilitate India’s transition into an industrial power. 
• International Technical Training: This included sending Indian students abroad for technical training, which was part of a broader strategy to develop a cadre of skilled professionals who could spearhead industrialization in India.
• Scientific Education and National Reconstruction: Bose’s emphasis on scientific education was a part of his comprehensive strategy for national reconstruction, acknowledging the importance of science and industry in the global context. 
  • His views on education were congruent with his modernist and internationalist outlook, which sought to prepare India for competitive participation in the global economy.
• Gandhi’s Emphasis on Moral Education and Rural Self-Sufficiency vs. Bose’s Focus on Industrial and Scientific Learning
• Gandhi’s education system focused on moral development and rural self-reliance, preparing individuals for a life grounded in ethical principles and community service. 
  • In contrast, Bose emphasized the need for India to cultivate industrial and scientific expertise to become self-reliant and economically progressive.
• Implications for Postcolonial India
• The educational models proposed by Gandhi and Bose carry significant implications for the direction of postcolonial India’s development. 
• Gandhi’s Nai Talim was a radical departure from conventional education, prioritizing the cultivation of virtues and self-sufficiency. 

Enroll now for UPSC Online Course

• Bose’s vision aligned with global trends emphasizing industrialization and scientific advancement, preparing India to take its place among the developed nations.

Conclusion

Gandhi and Bose’s divergent approaches to India’s social issues reflect the complexity of the independence struggle. Gandhi’s emphasis on moral reform and preservation of traditional values aimed to transform society from within, while Bose’s revolutionary vision sought to dismantle existing hierarchies and promote egalitarianism. Their differing ideologies on caste, women’s rights, and education shaped India’s path to social justice and continue to influence contemporary discussions on societal progress and equality.

Sign up for the PWOnlyIAS Online Course by Physics Wallah and start your journey to IAS success today!

DOWNLOAD PDF